Our Tiny Homestead
  • Home
  • Inside
    • Buy Nothing Challenge >
      • 2014
      • 2015
      • 2018
      • 2019 & Debt-Free
    • Our Wood Stove
    • Laundry
    • Prepare for a Power Outage
    • Renovations
  • Outside
    • Theresa's Gardening Goals
    • Permaculture 101
    • Perennial Vegetables
    • Eat Your Wild Yard
    • Seed Starting
    • Walnut Syrup
    • Gardening for Wildlife
    • Wildlife Pond
    • Save Our Bees
    • Our Gardens >
      • Celtic Cross Garden
      • Catio Construction
  • Cooking
    • Wood Stove Cooking
    • Shelf Chefing >
      • Bear's Shelf Chefing
      • In Shape Shelfchefing
      • Wild Raspberries
      • Grilled pizza
      • Celebrate Seasonal Eatin >
        • Samhain - Late Fall
      • Cook of Anarchy grilled cheese
    • Haybox Cooking
    • Heat wave solar cooking
    • Division of Labor
    • Recipes
  • Pantry
    • Pantry Intro
    • Pantry Cooking
    • Yearly Harvest List
    • Preserving
    • Making Staples
    • Growing Sprouts
    • Building Our Pantry
  • Celebrate
    • After the Pandemic
    • Winter Solstice
    • Mid-Winter & Imbolc
    • Spring Equinox
    • Late Spring & Beltane
    • Summer Solstice
    • Fall Equinox
    • Late Fall & Samhain
  • Our Books
  • Our Videos
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Resources
Picture

MAKING HOMEMADE 
ICE CREAM

Picture

Our First Video!

You're in for a treat- both for your taste buds and your funny bone:
  • Below are our usual step-by-step instructions on how to make the World's Best Honey Vanilla Ice Cream.
  • To the left is our first video, where you can see that we are learning how to do everything, from zooming to adding special features, while having fun laughing at ourselves. Watch as we open the churn to see what we've created.

Recipe for The World's Best Honey Vanilla

From Theresa: I have a few memories of making ice cream at my Aunt Barb's house when I was a little kid. She did all the preserving and making food from scratch that I'm trying to do now, and I loved helping her. However, I really hated the vanilla ice cream we made. I remember it being runny and tasting funny. Now that I'm older and my tastes have changed, I wanted to see if I liked homemade ice cream better. We bought a used and obnoxiously pink electric ice cream maker at a garage sale for $5. It came with a little booklet of recipes. I promptly modified one by exchanging honey for sugar, and accidently made the best ice cream I've ever tasted. Previously, my favorite was Ben and Jerry's World's Best Vanilla. Now it's this recipe:
World's Best Honey Vanilla
(For a 4 Quart Ice Cream Maker)
  • 2 cups milk
  • 2 cups local honey
  • 2 cups half and half
  • 4 cups whipping cream
  • 1 1/2 tablespoons vanilla extract

To use the ice cream machine, you'll also need:
  • two 7 pound bags of ice or one larger bag
  • rock salt (You can usually find this in the grocery store with the rest of the salt. Sometimes it is called ice cream salt.)

The Day Before, Make and Chill the Cream:

1. Put 2 cups of whole milk in a saucepan and warm until it is steaming. Don't let it boil. Turn off the heat and remove the pan from the warm burner.
Picture
2. Pour in 2 cups of local honey.


Picture
3. Stir in the honey, which will darken the milk.


Picture
4. Sometimes the milk curdles a little. We haven't figured out why. But it doesn't make any difference to the taste! So keep going. Bear says: Think of it as creamy... in chunks.
Picture
5. Stir in the rest of the ingredients: 2 cups half and half, 4 cups whipping cream, 1 1/2 tablespoons of vanilla.
Picture
6. Transfer the mixture to the can that goes with your ice cream maker.
Picture
7. Don't forget to enjoy a taste test. Bear says, "Only one, Theresa, only one." Theresa ignores him.
8. Chill cream in refrigerator for as long as possible, preferably overnight.
Picture
Picture

The Next Day, Freeze the Cream to Make Ice Cream!

1. Bear likes to put the bowls we'll be using in the freezer when we start making the ice cream, so it doesn't melt any faster when we fill the bowls.
Picture
2. Gather your supplies. Here's our electric ice cream maker. If yours came with instructions, you should use them. Following is how we use ours to make the World's Best Honey Vanilla.
Picture
3. We set up the ice cream maker in our kitchen sink, because the ice will make a bit of a mess. You could also set up outside near an outlet. The white paddle inside the pink bucket is called the dasher. When we plug in the machine, the dasher will go around and around, churning the cream while it freezes.
Picture
4. You'll need ice. We usually get it from the gas station: two smaller 7 lb. bags, or one of the larger ones should be enough. You may need to break it up into smaller chunks with a hammer so that it fits in the ice cream maker.

Picture
5. Take your cream out of the refrigerator. Bear likes to give it one more stir.
Picture
6. Insert the dasher/paddle into the metal can and put on the lid. The tip of the dasher sticks out above the lid.
Picture
7. The tip of the dasher goes into the hole in the middle of the motor. Notice that on the edge of the white motor drive there are rectangles that slip into the holes on the edge of the pink bucket.
Picture
8. When you get the holes all aligned, plug in the motor and if everything is attached correctly, the metal can will go around and around.
Picture
9. The bag of ice goes conveniently in the other sink.
Picture
10. Put a layer of ice in the bottom of the pink tub.
Picture
11. Then add a layer of rock salt.
Picture
12. Continue alternating layers of ice and salt until the tub is full.
Picture
13. Set a timer. The ice cream is ready after 45 minutes or when the cream gets so thick that the can stops turning of its own accord.

Picture
14. You have to stay with the ice cream, and keep adding layers of ice and salt as the ice melts. We use the handle of a wooden spoon to push the ice down into the tub so we can add more.
Picture
15. So keep adding ice...
Picture
16. ... and keep adding salt.
Picture
17. You'll know you're getting the cream cold enough if the outside of the tub gets frosted over.

Picture
18. At the end of the 45 minutes, or when the motor stops turning, unplug the machine. You'll probably have ice water almost to the top.
Picture
19. Remove the motor drive and brush any ice and salt off of the lid.
Picture
20. Remove the can of ice cream.  Are you excited yet?
Picture
21. Ta da! Here's how delightful it looks:
Picture
22. Remove the dasher.
Picture
23. Lick off the dasher...
Picture
24. ...or eat a spoonful.
Picture
25. Fill the bowls you're planning to eat right away. (Theresa hated it when it was this runny when she was a kid, but now she think it tastes best this way).
Picture
26. Bear likes to store the rest of the ice cream in glass bowls, because he doesn't like the taste of the metal can. Theresa like it better in the metal can.
Picture
27. We got two bowls full. Bear thinks he is larger and should get the fuller bowl... Theresa is immune to this logic.
Picture
28. Put the extra in the fridge. It will harden more, and be more like the consistency of store bought ice cream. 
Picture
29. You can leave the ice in the tub to melt, and the next day you can drain out the water and keep any rock salt that hasn't dissolved to use the next time you freeze ice cream.
Picture
30. Bear is eating his with his homemade chocolate coffee syrup on top.

Picture
31. Theresa is eating hers plain, because pure vanilla has always been her favorite flavor, and honey vanilla rocks.

Picture
32. This is the creamiest vanilla she's ever tasted. See how it leaves a coating on the edge of the bowl? It does the same thing in your mouth.
Picture

Enjoy!

You also might like our instructions for making walnut syrup ice cream with our hand crank ice cream maker, 
near the end of our walnut syrup page:
Picture
Picture
Picture
Home    Inside   Outside   Shelf Chefing   Cooking   Pantry   Celebrate   Our Books   Blog   About   Resources   Contact
Be the change you wish to see in the world.  ~Gandhi
Want to know when we add new content to our website?  Subscribe to our Blog.

These pages may contain affiliate links that allow us to share products we authentically recommend.
Clicking the links results in no extra cost to you, but we may receive a small commission that may someday help fund this work.

Copyright 2020 by Theresa & Rob Berrie